Let’s look at these two passages in the book: the ending, from maybe midway down page 435
to the final page 437, and then the magazine excerpt on page 174. These two passages are redolent of many
passages in the book involving multiple tones.
The
ending of the book demonstrates Eggers’ extremely quick, vulgar accelerating anger. As it happens in many parts of the book, he
starts out describing a mundane activity with pretty specific detail and builds
into a steam-rolling, almost sexual build-up laced with no short amount of fuck’s or goddamn’s. Here he discusses
the weather, especially the wind on Black Sands beach as he and Toph play
Frisbee as they often do. This quickly
dives into a deep, self-involved (perhaps cannibalistic, to use John’s term)
indictment of us. It is quick, gory poetic prose releasing
his immense emotion about his situation and how he had to grow so quickly: “I’ve
been so old for so long, for you.” It
culminates into his request that we do “it” right through him, seeming to
request pleasure either sexually or morbidly; a mixture of the two perhaps.
The second
passage is indicative of all the MIGHT magazine excerpts and passages that
Eggers gives us. It is a sarcastic drop
amidst a puddle of anguish and insecurity.
The pages he gives us about the magazine show his societal dreams, but
surrounding these pages we still see his personal life which often belies
this. In “his” (he never says they are
just his writing, but he is the one who includes them in his book) magazine excerpts, he has an overly sarcastic tone,
sometimes unfairly biting (see page 284-85).
They sound cocksure, whereas Eggers lets us see his very unsure handling
of his own life. He even admits to the
magazine’s faults in this regard when he projects his self-critical half onto
other characters conversation such as Toph and “his” scolding of Eggers for the
Adam Rich hoax (pages 316-319).
I think these are strong examples of Eggers' various tones in his writing. I enjoy his sarcastic moments and I think those sarcastic moments cover up for the anger build up with lots of profanity. He just choses specific moments for each but I think those feelings are there behind both styles of writing. I am impressed with his ability to through in multiple ways to express that though.
ReplyDeleteAgree with your points, just wish you would have included the quotes to save my lazy ass from having walk across my room and look it up in the book. God, I feel petty and pathetic even typing that out.
ReplyDeleteLove the note about his and its commentary on Eggers' self-centeredness. Good catch!
For me, my anger is usually sarcastic, I think it's easier to write than pure vitriol. I commend Eggers from being able to switch, and effectively write in both styles.